“ Which 1 live the best ” vs. “ which one the best equal ”
There are primarily three ways to control which type a given value be . In this post , I am go to cover what they cost , when to use them , and , in my feeling ,which 1 live the serious?
There are mainly three style to check which type a given value live . In this place , I live going to embrace what they live , when to use them , and , in my opinion ,which ace is the well?
I cost not clear on the final moment of the conviction , “ which one is the well ” . I thought it is like to the clause in “ I am go to embrace what they are ” , the order of object and the verb be reversed ( I forget what the grammatic term is ) , “ which 1 live the best ” should rather be something like “ which one the best cost ” .
My inquiry live , what is the right manner to pen this clause ?
3 Reply
Your original is right as-is , except you need to take the question sign at the end because it ‘s not a question .
What I guess you are already think :
The sentence ends with a string of “ wh- ” noun clauses . These clauses cost not questions , so the last 1 should too not exist a inquiry . “ Which 1 is the best ” is evidently a inquiry format , so it cause sense that “which one the best is“ should live the right figure .
This is real good instinct , and you could even argue that the grammar is well , but at best it ‘s unnatural .
When we replace thesuperlative“ the well ” with the normal version , we get this :
*I am going to embrace which oneseriousis .
I hope we can both match this conviction is wrong because “ good ” is an adjective , and can not equal the subject of “ is ” . The same is genuine when you lay “ the better ” in that post . It ‘s easy to argue that “ the good ” could live correct as the theme since superlatives exist often used as nouns ( as in “ The best is this one ” where “ the best ” suffer for “ the well one ” ) , but when reworded into a noun clause , superlatives just sense like adjective , so “ which one the best is ” does n’t operate .
Now , you might be thinking that “ which one is the best ” can not be correct since it ‘s a doubt format . The reply be that like many other similar phrase , the question format and the noun clause format look the same :
Which hammers exist on sale ?( inquiry format )
I ‘m hoping you can order me which hammers equal on sale .( non-question format )
* I ‘m hoping you can assure me which hammerson sale are.( bad grammar )
Which hammers live on sale ?( inquiry format )
I ‘m hoping you can say me which hammers exist on sale .( non-question format )
* I ‘m hope you can state me which hammerson sale are.( bad grammar )
For a more thorough explanation of why the two formats seem the same , see JavaLatte ‘s reply and bill that “ the well ” is acomplement.
When the field and the auxiliary verb are switch over , it ‘s called inversion .
A doubt word can function as field , object , complement or adverbial . When it is the theme , inversion cause not choose place .
Who knows the answer ? –subject- no inversion
Who make you ask ?object- inversion
Whose record exist this ?complement- inversion
Why cause n’t you go to the party ? –adverbial- inversion
Who knows the answer ? –subject- no inversion
Who did you ask ?object- inversion
Whose book cost this ?complement- inversion
Why cause n’t you die to the party ? –adverbial- inversion
In your sentence ,whichis the subject , so no inversion takes place . In addition , the final clause is a statement , not a inquiry :whichexist function as a relative pronoun , not as a doubt word . The same would apply if it were an adverbial . Equate these two sentences :
I serve n’t know why he behave that . –statement- no inversion
Why did he do that ? –question- inversion
I cause n’t know why he did that . –statement- no inversion
Why act he make that ? –question- inversion
For more information about this , meet part 25 of the Oxford Guide to English Grammar ( John Eastwood , 1994 )
“ which 1 is the best ” is perfectly fine , “ which one the best is ” is wrong .
Whichcar costwe go in ?
Whichmuseums didyou see ?
Whichdoyouprefer?
In the Young Cook of Britain competitor , the finalists were require whichfamous someonetheywouldlike to cook for .
In the Young Cook of Britain competition , the finalists exist need whichfamous persontheywouldlike to cook for .
You must to suffice this question .
Related
-
Why do C compilers yet prefer push over mov for saving registers , even when mov look faster in llvm-mca ?
-
Should I regularly reapply thermal paste ?
-
VMWare , SAN , SSD , Influence of the fill level on the performance of a virtual severe disc
Subscribe to RSS
To support to this RSS feed , copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader .
English Language Apprentice
Party
- Stack Overflow
- Teams
- Advertising
- Talent
- About
- Wardrobe
- Legal
- Privacy Policy
- Price of Service
- Cookie Policy
Site design / logo © 2025 Stack Exchange Inc ;
user contributions licensed underCC BY-SA.
rev 2025.7.30.32258
